Grading Guidelines
General Grading Principles
The Victorian Pipers’ Association (VPA) grading system is designed to provide an appropriate competitive pathway for pipers of all ages and levels of experience, from those entering solo competition for the first time through to advanced and expert-level competitors.
Except where specifically stated otherwise, progression through the grades is based primarily on demonstrated playing standard rather than the length of time a competitor has spent in a particular grade or purely on their results during the season.
When considering a regrading, the VPA Grading Panel may take into account a competitor’s:
- overall playing standard;
- competition results;
- consistency of performance;
- standard and strength of the competitor field;
- recommendations from judges;
- consultation with tutors, where appropriate; and
- any relevant appeal or submission made by the competitor.
Competition results alone do not automatically determine whether a piper should be upgraded.
The same general grading principles apply to both Light Music and Piobaireachd.
For the purposes of these guidelines:
- Light Music refers to the 2/4 March, Strathspey and Reel, and Hornpipe and Jig events, as applicable to each grade.
- Element refers to an individual competition event or musical requirement forming part of a contest.
- VPA Grading Panel refers to the panel responsible for considering the appropriate grading, upgrading, regrading and appeals of competitors.
- Regrading refers to the movement of a competitor to a higher or lower grade where their current playing standard is no longer considered consistent with the requirements of their existing grade.
- Prescribed Tune List refers to the list of Piobaireachd approved by the VPA Grading Panel for the relevant grade or grades.
- Set List refers to the Piobaireachd repertoire prescribed by the VPA Grading Panel for a particular competition season.
- Appeal Process and Submission refers to competitors appealing their assigned grade via written appeal to the Grading Panel. Audio/Video recordings will usually be required by the Grading Panel for consideration of the appeal.
Grading Appeals – Eligibility and Submission Requirements
Competitors may appeal their assigned grade from the conclusion of the contest season until 31 January of the following year. All grading appeals must be submitted to the VPA Grading Panel via email at [email protected], accompanied by audio and/or video recordings demonstrating the competitor’s playing standard.
Appeals must meet the following requirements:
Submission Period: Grading appeals may be submitted from the conclusion of the contest season until 31 January of the following year. Appeals received outside this period will not be considered.
Light Music Requirements: Competitors must submit recordings of both Light Music elements (Elements 1 and 2) prescribed for the grade they are seeking. For example, where applicable, this would include a 2/4 March and a Strathspey and Reel.
Piobaireachd Requirements: Competitors must submit recordings that fulfil the Piobaireachd tune requirements of the grade they are seeking. For example:
C Grade: One complete Piobaireachd.
D Grade: The Ground and First Variation of a Piobaireachd.
Assessment: All grading appeals will be reviewed by the VPA Grading Panel, with consideration given to the competitor’s demonstrated playing standard and suitability for the requested grade.
Submission of a grading appeal does not guarantee regrading. All decisions regarding grading appeals remain at the discretion of the VPA Grading Panel.
Playing Up – Eligibility and Conditions
Competitors may be eligible to compete in the next higher grade during the contest season, subject to the following conditions:
Eligibility: A competitor must have achieved either an overall win in Light Music or a first placing in a Piobaireachd event in their assigned grade to be eligible to play up.
Discipline Restrictions: Competitors may only play up in a discipline in which they have achieved the qualifying result. An overall win in Light Music permits a competitor to play up in Light Music only, while a first placing in a Piobaireachd event permits a competitor to play up in Piobaireachd only. Eligibility in one discipline does not confer eligibility to play up in the other.
Assigned Grade Participation: Competitors who elect to play up must also compete in their assigned grade in the same discipline at that contest.
Grade Restrictions: Competitors may only play up one grade above their assigned grade.
Tune Requirements: Competitors playing up must fulfil all tune requirements prescribed for the higher grade in which they are competing.
Exclusions: Playing up is not permitted at the first contest of the season or at the Victorian Championships. At these events, all competitors must compete exclusively in their assigned grade.
Eligibility to play up does not constitute formal regrading. Competitors retain their assigned grade unless otherwise determined by the VPA Grading Panel.
Novice Grade
Purpose and Standard
Novice Grade is suitable for pipers of all ages and is intended as an introductory grade for pipers beginning their competitive solo piping journey.
Novice Grade will generally be suitable for pipers who meet most or all of the following criteria:
- have only relatively recently progressed to the full bagpipe, generally within the preceding 12–18 months;
- have not regularly competed with more than two parts of a 2/4 March in a solo competition;
- have not yet progressed to performing Strathspeys and Reels;
- are new to solo competition, generally competing in their first or second season.
The VPA recognises that individual pipers develop at different rates. These criteria should therefore be considered together when determining whether Novice Grade remains appropriate for a competitor.
Light Music Requirements
Novice Grade competitors must be capable of performing:
- a basic two-part simple-time march, such as a 2/4 March; and
- 16 bars of a Slow Air or Slow March-style tune.
The Slow Air or Slow March requirement may consist of either:
- a one-part tune played twice; or
- a two-part tune with each part played once.
Piobaireachd Requirements
For Piobaireachd, competitors are required to perform the Ground only.
Tunes must be selected from the VPA C, D and Novice Prescribed Tune List.
Progression from Novice Grade
Novice Grade is intended to provide competitors with an introduction to solo competition rather than operate as a permanent competitive grade.
As a general principle, pipers should progress from Novice Grade after one or two seasons of competition, following consultation between the piper, their tutor where applicable, and the VPA Grading Panel.
After two seasons of competition, a piper who believes they are not yet ready to progress to D Grade may appeal to the VPA Grading Panel for permission to remain in Novice Grade.
The same progression principles apply to the Piobaireachd grade.
A Novice Grade competitor may elect to upgrade to D Grade during a competition season. Once the competitor has upgraded and competed in D Grade, they may not subsequently return to Novice Grade.
Tuning Assistance
Novice Grade competitors may receive tuning assistance in the competition room before each element.
Tuning assistance must cease before the competitor commences their performance.
D Grade
Purpose and Standard
D Grade is suitable for pipers of all ages and is the VPA’s lowest competitive grade, as distinct from Novice Grade, which is intended primarily as an introductory grade.
D Grade is intended for pipers who:
- have gained experience at Novice level or otherwise demonstrate a playing standard above Novice Grade;
- are capable of performing four parts of 2/4 March music; and
- are capable of performing a two-part Strathspey and two-part Reel as a set.
Light Music Requirements
D Grade competitors must be capable of performing:
- four parts of 2/4 March music; and
- a two-part Strathspey followed by a two-part Reel.
To assist with the transition from Novice Grade to D Grade, the four-part 2/4 March requirement may be satisfied by either:
- one four-part 2/4 March; or
- two different two-part 2/4 Marches played consecutively.
Piobaireachd Requirements
For Piobaireachd, competitors are required to perform the Ground and first variation.
Tunes must be selected from the VPA C, D and Novice Prescribed Tune List.
Progression from D Grade
Pipers will not automatically be upgraded from D Grade based on the length of time spent in competition.
Upgrade decisions will be based on the competitor’s demonstrated playing standard, competition results, consistency, the standard of the competitor field, recommendations from judges, tutor consultation where appropriate, and consideration by the VPA Grading Panel.
The same conditions apply to Piobaireachd.
For example, a competitor may have a successful season and finish among the leading competitors in the Piper of the Year standings without yet demonstrating the overall playing standard required for C Grade.
Conversely, a competitor may achieve relatively few high placings because of absences, performance breakdowns or non-completions, while nevertheless demonstrating an overall playing standard consistent with C Grade.
Tuning Assistance
D Grade competitors may receive tuning assistance in the competition room before each element.
Tuning assistance must cease before the competitor commences their performance.
C Grade
Purpose and Standard
C Grade is suitable for pipers of all ages and is the first VPA competitive grade requiring competitors to demonstrate the ability to perform full Light Music tunes and to manage their instrument independently in the competition environment.
C Grade competitors are expected to:
- have exceeded the playing standard required for D Grade;
- perform four-part Light Music tunes with an intermediate understanding of musical expression, tempo and technical execution;
- demonstrate reasonably consistent tone and sound production appropriate to the standard of the grade;
- demonstrate sufficient stamina and instrument control to complete all required competition elements while maintaining an appropriate standard of sound; and
- demonstrate a basic ability to tune and prepare their instrument independently in the competition room.
Competitors at this level should also have an understanding of, or seek appropriate advice regarding, the standard and suitability of tunes being presented in competition. Advice may be sought from a tutor or the VPA Grading Panel.
Light Music Requirements
C Grade competitors must be capable of performing:
- a minimum four-part 2/4 March;
- a minimum four-part Strathspey followed by a four-part Reel; and
- a minimum four-part Hornpipe followed by a four-part Jig.
Piobaireachd Requirements
C Grade competitors are required to perform a complete Piobaireachd through the Crunluath and Crunluath a Mach, where applicable.
Tunes must be selected from the VPA C, D and Novice Prescribed Tune List.
Progression from C Grade
Pipers will not automatically be upgraded from C Grade based on the length of time spent in competition.
Upgrade decisions will be based on the competitor’s demonstrated playing standard, competition results, consistency, the standard of the competitor field, recommendations from judges, tutor consultation where appropriate, and consideration by the VPA Grading Panel.
The same conditions apply to Piobaireachd.
For example, a competitor may have a successful season and finish among the leading competitors in the Piper of the Year standings without yet demonstrating the overall playing standard required for B Grade.
Conversely, a competitor may achieve relatively few high placings because of absences, performance breakdowns or non-completions, while nevertheless demonstrating an overall playing standard consistent with B Grade.
Tuning Assistance
C Grade competitors may not receive tuning assistance in the competition room during any part of their performance, including between elements.
B Grade
Purpose and Standard
B Grade is suitable for pipers of all ages and is intended for accomplished pipers with relevant experience and demonstrated ability in the competitive solo piping environment.
B Grade competitors are expected to:
- have exceeded the playing standard required for C Grade;
- perform four-part Light Music tunes with an intermediate to advanced understanding of musical expression, tempo and technical execution;
- demonstrate consistent sound production, instrument control and tuning;
- demonstrate an appropriate standard of repertoire for B Grade competition; and
- be capable of competing in all three Light Music elements where required by the competition format.
Competitors at this level should have an understanding of, or seek appropriate advice regarding, the standard and suitability of tunes being presented in competition. Advice may be sought from a tutor or the VPA Grading Panel.
Light Music Requirements
B Grade competitors must be capable of performing:
- a minimum four-part 2/4 March;
- a minimum four-part Strathspey followed by a minimum four-part Reel; and
- a minimum four-part Hornpipe followed by a minimum four-part Jig.
Competitors are required to submit two tunes from each required tune category for selection by the judge or judges before commencing their performance.
This will normally comprise:
- two 2/4 Marches;
- two Strathspeys;
- two Reels;
- two Hornpipes; and
- two Jigs.
The judge or judges will select one tune from each required category.
For paired events, selected tunes may be drawn from different numbered submissions. For example, Strathspey No. 1 may be selected with Reel No. 2.
Piobaireachd Requirements
B Grade competitors are required to submit two complete Piobaireachds, each to be performed through the Crunluath and Crunluath a Mach where applicable.
Tunes must be selected from the B Grade Set List, which will be determined by the VPA Grading Panel and may change from season to season.
The judge or judges will select one of the submitted tunes for performance.
The competitor will be informed of the selected tune by the contest steward when the preceding competitor has entered the competition room.
Note: The number of tunes required for submission may vary depending on the requirements of the relevant season or set list. For example, additional tunes may be required during an own-choice season.
Progression from B Grade
Pipers will not automatically be upgraded from B Grade based on the length of time spent in competition.
Upgrade decisions will be based on the competitor’s demonstrated playing standard, competition results, consistency, the standard of the competitor field, recommendations from judges, tutor consultation where appropriate, and consideration by the VPA Grading Panel.
The same conditions apply to Piobaireachd.
Promotion from B Grade to A Grade will be subject to a higher threshold, reflecting the advanced standard expected of A Grade competitors.
A B Grade competitor may also be considered for regrading to C Grade where their playing standard is no longer considered consistent with the requirements of B Grade.
Any such regrading will be considered by the VPA Grading Panel following consultation with the competitor and, where appropriate, relevant judges and tutors.
Tuning Assistance
B Grade competitors may not receive tuning assistance in the competition room during any part of their performance, including between elements.
A Grade
Purpose and Standard
A Grade is suitable for pipers of all ages and is intended for highly accomplished competitive pipers who demonstrate an advanced to expert standard of musical expression, technique, instrument control and sound production.
A Grade competitors are expected to:
- have exceeded the playing standard required for B Grade;
- perform all required Light Music with an advanced to expert understanding of musical expression, tempo and technical execution;
- demonstrate advanced capability on the bagpipe, including tuning, tone, instrument control and consistency of sound production;
- demonstrate an appropriate standard of repertoire for A Grade competition; and
- be capable of competing in all three Light Music elements where required by the competition format.
Competitors at this level should have an understanding of, or seek appropriate advice regarding, the standard and suitability of tunes being presented in competition. Advice may be sought from a tutor or the VPA Grading Panel.
Light Music Requirements
A Grade competitors must be capable of performing:
- a minimum four-part 2/4 March;
- a minimum four-part Strathspey followed by a minimum four-part Reel; and
- a minimum four-part Hornpipe followed by a minimum four-part Jig.
Competitors are required to submit three tunes from each required tune category for selection by the judge or judges before commencing their performance.
This will normally comprise:
- three 2/4 Marches;
- three Strathspeys;
- three Reels;
- three Hornpipes; and
- three Jigs.
The judge or judges will select one tune from each required category.
For paired events, selected tunes may be drawn from different numbered submissions. For example, Strathspey No. 1 may be selected with Reel No. 2.
Piobaireachd Requirements
A Grade competitors are required to submit three complete Piobaireachd, each to be performed through the Crunluath and Crunluath a Mach where applicable.
Tunes must be selected from the A Grade Set List, which will be determined by the VPA Grading Panel and may change from season to season.
The judge or judges will select one of the submitted tunes for performance.
The competitor will be informed of the selected tune by the contest steward when the preceding competitor has entered the competition room.
Note: The number of tunes required for submission may vary depending on the requirements of the relevant season or set list. For example, additional tunes may be required during an own-choice season.
Regrading from A Grade
An A Grade competitor may be considered for regrading to B Grade where their playing standard is no longer considered consistent with the requirements of A Grade.
Any such regrading will be considered by the VPA Grading Panel following consultation with the competitor and, where appropriate, relevant judges and tutors.
The same conditions apply to Piobaireachd.
Tuning Assistance
A Grade competitors may not receive tuning assistance in the competition room during any part of their performance, including between elements.

